Ok so we had some disagreement in my clan about whether one thrall would get more XP than another when farming together, and after some careful testing I figured out what was going on.
This was on Xbox official PvP, so any PS4 and PC people that have/will try this please ring in, also PVE to see if there is a difference.
Killing a frost giant with just me and Thrally McThrallface: 129,600 XP.
Killing a frost giant with me, Thrally, a clan mate, and his thrall: 97,200 XP each.
Is farming together really supposed to net you less XP? Why is Funcom trying so hard to discourage clan play (thrall limits, XP, etc)?
Farming in group is way faster than going alone even if it is less exp.
Every game where you can team up with buddies has a system similar to this since, maybe, the beggining of times.
Twice the people and thralls equals approximately twice the rate of killing. If the exp numbers you present are accurate, you’re getting ~3/4 exp rate per enemy, which doubles into ~1.5x exp you’d get if you spent the same amount of time killing alone. Whereas exp/kill is less, exp/minute is actually significantly more. I’m surprised the xp rate is so advantageous towards groups because it’s faster kills and less risk.
Are you playing on an Official or a Private server? When I kill a Frost Giant on a PvE Official, I’m getting only 32,400 for a solo kill on one of them. Is this why people keep saying they can level a thrall to 20 in only 5 hours?!
That 5 hr thing probably depends which thrall. On my server with everything at default it took me ~ 10 hrs or so of solid kill farming to get Erii to 20 (2 days real time mixing in other stuff) but thugra took 2 hrs to get to 15 which looks finishable to 20 in maybe another 1-2.
It just royally ■■■■■■ me off getting thrown under the bus like this once again just because I play PvE. I’d been scratching my head wondering why they require sooo much damned XP, but if they were balanced around the rate on PvP servers, then it makes a lot more sense.
A 2x difference like with the gathering rates would be one thing, but FOUR TIMES is a slap in the face.