Feedback & Suggestions

suggestion

#175

About bound to character agent booster pack loot, unbinding would also make people buy more. I bought some, felt very annoyed as the agents and gear were character bound, won’t buy again unless the content is made tradable.


#176

Okay, I can’t take this anymore. There is no such thing as a failure in the Agent System, alright? There are three mission finish states: Complete, Success and Outstanding (which is the “critical success” that Andrew mentions in the video).

Complete is the “failure” state. Even when you complete, you get all the experience stated in the UI. So if the UI said you’d get 1000 xp, you still get 1000 xp. There is no mission state that grants 0 xp. Okay? Some missions not granting experience is a bug. The bug doesn’t happen only when you “complete”, it can also happen when you succeed. I’ve had it happen two times so far and it seems to be tied to the crash.

Success is the default success state. When you succeed, you get the items listed AND you get an experience bonus. So if the mission originally said you’d get 1000 xp, you now get I don’t know 1250 or something. Are we clear?

Outstanding is the critical success state. You get all the items listed and a bigger experience bonus. If the missions originally said 1000 xp, now you get (again I don’t know the exact value) 1500 or something.

Affinity is your combined success chance. If it is a 100%, you will either succeed regularly or critically. I have taken a look into the Agent System UI code. “Affinity” is obtained by a method internally referred to as GetSuccessChanceForAgent. If your affinity is 100% you will always succeed. You will absolutely get an item. Jesus Christ.


#177

[pve][misc][mission][thesetagsaredumb]

Message to Hell mission in Kaidan. If someone clears the little camp just ahead of you, you might as well drop the mission and leave. It takes 5 minutes to respawn.


#178

Hate to burst your bubble, but you have not told me anything new. I know how it should work, but that is not how it currently works, and until its actually fixed I will continue to describe it as it functions now.

Which is we run missions we don’t get experience. Thereby making every mission I run a crapshoot of getting experience until its fixed, which could be tonight, tomorrow or not until Season 2 drops. If thats the case, how I’ve described it is completely accurate. I’m not going to run multiple missions that grant no exp and go “gosh, its a bug, oh well.” I’m going to describe what I see. That is I’m successful yet get no exp. The text blurbs should reflect that status as well, not go “WOW you’re amazing!” when its just a ‘completed’ mission.

Regardless, I get no exp running missions, will I get that exp back? highly unlikely. That makes using the agent system pointless for me. BTW, I’ve not gotten exp 5 missions in a row on 2 agents. Did. Not. Crash. Once. So please stop stating that is the cause, or even might be the cause. It is not.

Accept the fact that others may be aware of things you are not and perhaps if the developers stop tying the two problems together, they may actually look for the bug in a new location instead of trying to figure out why they can’t find the reason behind the crash & the no exp bug in the same place.


#179

I doubt they make you jump higher, it just clips against the mesh differently than regular jumping so it pulls you up while animations cannot. At least that’s my theory.

I prefer the ninja sprint because it has a unique animation set (is that the only one that does?) but the jumping flips simply cannot catch the edge of objects the way bikes or even hoverboards do. Its very annoying and time consuming to switch sprints just to make a jump.


#180

Not true. Failure looks a lot like Mission Complete, but with less loot. See the first box under “Rewards”? All missions have something there, but if you fail, you don’t get that item.


^ Failure


^ Success

So there are four states: Failure Complete, Successful Complete, Success, and Outstanding. XP and assets are granted for all four (provided the game isn’t bugging–the XP from that Success didn’t stick, Faction Mook remained level 23.)

To which: [Feedback] It’s really hard to see the difference between a failed mission and a succeeded one at a glance, which is obviously confusing people! Could it be made a little more obvious in some way that doesn’t lead people to think they get nothing for a failure? Maybe a different color glow on a succeeded Mission Complete to set it apart from a failed Mission Complete?


#181

It seems to bring us back to the point that 100% affinity is not Success+Outstanding :wink:


#182

Your 2nd screenshot is of a bugged Success mission, it isn’t an intended state of the game. real “Complete” is as you show, the Faction Recruit saying ‘■■■■ ■■■■ ■■■■’ and getting less xp.

I’ve been logging every mission I do and the only time you’ll get a mismatch like that is on 0 xp missions, so it’s actually a worse finishing state in practical terms than your ‘fail complete’ (which will usually give xp at least)


#183

[Misc] Agents go incapacitated for 8+ hours and seem to cost just shy of 1000 MoF per hour. Why is this? If they are supposed to be lesser to us why does it cost 7-8K to fully recover an Agent that just got a sucessful mission, but if we lose all of our essence it costs us at max 1000 shards.

This should at very least have an option for MoF or shards. I understand the rewards being sorta lame based on the effort on our end, but its not a worthwhile sink for the amount of MoF you are asking. The hurt of this could also be lessened if Agents had a better drop rate. I wonder how many people played all weekend long and didn’t get any drops?


#184

[PVE] Solo Player End Game

I vastly prefer to play solo. This is largely due to a limited schedule and not wanting to inflict my play style on others. I feel the end game progression loop for solo players is pretty lacking in general. I feel that nothing beyond Scenarios are really worth my time. Soloing low tier Elite dungeons is painful, spotty and takes too long. It’s obviously not designed for a single player to complete. In general, rewards across the board are pretty anemic, far too random and time consuming to open. The exception to this was container key runs. But now, the distillate yields from these runs are way too random. Sometimes I end up with around a total of 2500cc worth of distillates and othertimes almost 10x that. The overall reward experience is frustrating and each session end has me asking myself: Why am I playing this game? I really want to love SWL, but just about every feature has me wondering why I would use/play/pay for it.

Suggestions:

  1. Consider ditching reward bags altogether when you hit Tokyo. Missions could reward low yield distillates.
    1b) As an alternative to the above, you could have reward bags have a chance to award distillates (between 250cc and 500cc).
  2. Remove 1 or more layer of randomness from the container key experience. Currently there are two: 1 from opening the grimy key and another from looting the container boss.
    2a) Remove the chance to get anima shards instead of a key, always grant a key. Randomly not getting a key, when your goal is to get a key feels awful. Instead, reduce anima shards rewarded from bosses to something like: 1000/3000/5000. Don’t award cosmetic items if the player already owns them. Replace all cosmetic items with gadgets, pets or distillates. Overall distillate cc yield would probably need to be reduced to make this not break things.
    2b) Increase the chance to get a container key from a grimy key and increase the anima shards from not getting a container key. This makes the experience of not getting a key feel better. Additionally ensure that the player always gets a distillate upon killing a container boss.
  3. Add more solo focused challenging content with multiple levels of difficulty like Scenarios. This type of content doesn’t splinter the player base like multi-tiered group content does. I was really hoping Orochi Tower would end up like this, but there’s no real reason to run through it more than once. A total shame.

My line of thinking is that group gameplay should be significantly more rewarding than solo content. That said, I think rewards outside of Scenarios is just lacking, especially when it comes to distillates.

Thanks for reading,

T


#185

[PVE] Agent Network

I’ve played (and still play) a lot of MMOs that have systems like this: Star Trek Online’s Duty Officer system, Star Trek Online’s Admiralty system, World of Warcraft’s follower missions, Rift’s Minions, etc. I feel that the Agent Network analyzed individual components of these kinds of systems, but not how they work together. Or why each of these components exist. As a result, the Agent Network suffers from the following major issues: three layers of monetization (2 hard and 1 soft), large barrier to entry (very time consuming and random or expensive and random to acquire new agents), unsatisfying rewards (low distillate cc yield), needless penalties (incapacitation), poor user experience (UI is needlessly complicated, very small text, success chance is really confusing, no indicator as to when my agent will be incapacitated) and 3 currencies that you need to generate and carefully manage. In general, I feel this system suffers from a general fear of rewarding the player in any meaningful way even if they’ve invested significant money or time into the system. Whenever I use this feature, I end up asking myself the following questions:

-Why would I use this? I throw away all the distillates I get because they’re not worth applying.
-Because of the above concern, why would I invest time and/or cash into this system?

I realize that there are additional tiers, but if I am feeling unrewarded at lower tiers, I am not strongly incentivized to keep progressing. In short, I really want to like this system as I am a big fan of offline progression systems like this, but it suffers from a lot of problems that really make it painful to interact with.

Suggestions:

  1. Consider rewarding players with a specific agent at certain player level milestones: 15 (Faction Recruit), 20 (New Agent), 30 (New Agent), 40 (New Agent), 50 (New Agent). These agents should be awarded retroactively to players who have already achieved these levels.
  2. Significantly increase the distillate rewards. Never award less than 250cc or make all distillates purified, that just feels…bad. I frequently hear the argument against doing this “but it’s passive gameplay”. This is true, but it’s passive gameplay you can spend real money on and spend real time on to grind out agents, so the rewards should reflect this.
  3. I spent $40 on this feature and completely regret it. That’s a pretty awful feeling when you spend money on a game. Dial back the monetization or make spending cash worth the player’s investment:
    3a) Increase the value of Agent Boosters: I feel like the items awarded need to be either worth more hex coins, or the hex coin prices need to drop a lot. Increase the likelihood that an agent will drop. Completely remove green equipment bags. Consider awarding two items, one of which has a high chance of awarding an agent. If you receive a duplicate agent, you should be able to exchange it for another of a equal or lesser quality.
  4. Increase the frequency and reduce the randomness of earning agents. The latter part of this should really be applied to all rewards in SWL.
  5. Allow the player to earn each of the 3 currencies equally (unless supplies and intel are supposed to be more rare… not sure if this is intentional). I never have enough intel and supplies.
  6. Simplify how success is explained to the player. 100% is a blatant falsehood. It’s way more complex than that and I don’t think it needs to be. I think STO did this really well with Admiralty.

In conclusion, I really want to like this system, but I feel it really isn’t worth investing time or money into at this time.

Thanks for reading,

T


#186

[Interface]

Chat: Color-selection for different chats would be nice

I’m not a big fan of mods, so I don’t know if there’s anything like that around. Even if there is… would like to see it as a regular feature. Hope this wasn’t already mentioned…


#187

[Items/Pets] We need a rocket jump gadget.


#188

[Uh, Items? Misc? Agentry Angst?]

I thought of a possible solution for the low level distillates are worse than junk issue we are running into with the agent system (apologies if it has already been mentioned). Why not change the anima shard worth of distillates entirely? Instead of being required to use a higher amount of anima shards for distillates (any distillate at all) on the empowerment of higher level gear, why not eliminate this system all together and instead charge us anima shard costs according to the level of the actual distillate, therein requiring that the most powerful distillates in the game cost whatever amount of shards it takes to currently use a distillate on legendary items, with the least powerful distillates (those in the very first tier of the agent system) costing us the amount of anima shards (or slightly less) then we currently use to empower a green item? This way we are still paying more anima shards to empower our gear with more xp (when using larger xp distillates) but also paying a fair price in anima shards to empower our gear with a lot less xp from the smaller distillates.


#189

[Agent Network][Crafting][Items] Anima Distillery / Purification / Alchemy

These new little agents sure bring back a lot of scraps of distillates. I thought it was strange how common distillates were before, but now they’re like copper pieces. The little ones are too common to be worth picking up. So who’s out there, distilling anima from all the mission reward fodder we vendor for shards?

The item description says distillates are a conglomeration of anima /distilled/ from discarded weapons. There is explicitly a distillation process. And the good ones, the valuable ones, are purified versions of that stuff. So there must be a purification process as well. And it can’t be that hard if our handlers have subscribed all of us to weekly deliveries of it.

So, what’s the process, and why aren’t we doing it ourselves? Is the equipment too bulky? Does it require specific expertise and reagents that aren’t otherwise useful in the field, so nobody bothers teaching us?

How about we make contact with our faction’s alchemist (these skills are too useful for them not to employ at least one) and get them to turn these scraps Ms. Recruit brings back into something useful? If we could do a mission for them to get a still and condense little bits of distillate into that to make a decent vial worth using, these little mission rewards would be actually worthwhile.

Maybe it only costs 50 shards to empower the still or something, then we could fill that up and use it to empower something that costs more. Like some folks have been doing with green items, but even cheaper because a 150cc distillate isn’t even worth using on a green item. At 50 shards, it should be, even if we waste 60% of the XP by transferring it later from the still to the final target. It would be nice if we could do this without losing quite as much, though. Maybe make another step of taking the full still back to the alchemist to make a Distillate out of it that converts, say, 75% of the still’s XP into CCs of distillate, instead of 40% XP recovery. Maybe even have a purification process available that loses a little more of the XP, maybe down to 60%, but still better than 40% and reduces the cost to use it to 0.

Maybe the process requires tools and materials and reagents and some work that would translate into a mission we complete for the alchemist to get our final result. Maybe there are even several available missions in different difficulties for different capacity stills and distillates.

Maybe we could even get our agents involved in this process and make a Special Assignment to go assist the alchemist and return with some component of this process, like an empty still, if they do a decent job of his errands. Unlocked after we’ve done it ourselves, I would think.


#190

Just making the agent system give purified distillates is a much better solution though. Adding some complicated new system that achieves the same goal is just making busywork for both the players and the devs.


#191

[Agent System] For me at least, there’s a massive imbalance between missions yielding the different resource types. I am starting to get doubts whether missions yielding Supplies even exist; they’re probably a rumor spread by the Illuminati.

Personally, I’d prefer to see the balance of resource-yielding missions improved, but a button that charges a lot of Aurum to refresh the available missions might better fit the overall system design.


#193

[agent system]
After testing the feature the few days, I can’t see the point.
Put yourself in a 15th level new player’s shoes. He’s got one agent, yay!
But will he grind the missions to get others ? No. Because he’s struggling with his weapon choice, his builds, the akabs and all he wants is to find beaumont. And also because he just can’t quick roll on mission with his little combat power.
After use the feature a bit and see his agent incapacited, will he pay the MoF ? He may not have them.
So what will he do ? Stop using this feature.
Until he can grind the missions, have some MoF, and definitively do not need those distillates.

May be you could change that by:

  • Picking only one mission in a map and add agent loot on it, with better rate drop. With some little maths, you could replace the low drop rate by the missions cooldowns in term in feature longevity, wich may be less frustrating for players.
  • Have a better explained and designed system of incapacity. Or delete it.

#194

Looks like you aren’t just a jerk to me. It’s everybody. I thought we had something special, and this is how you repay me?

However, there is a fail state. The failure state is simply called “complete” in-game. It is absolutely a failure state, though. There are always minimum rewards given, even for failed missions. Namely, whatever three agent resources for that mission are and the xp. That’s all you get. The mission complete text for most of the agent missions for this fail state actually use the word “fail” or “failed” or some other synonym.

I think this is a bug. When you get a “Mission Complete” that actually gives you item rewards, I believe they really should be “Mission Success” instead. I would speculate this is related to the problem that @Glaucon described where the servers are sending old data to the game client which is what’s causing the xp bug.


#195

Glass houses mate.

It’s pretty clear that what @Vandelay is saying is that there’s not a hidden fourth state where the game says “Mission Completed” but actually gives you no rewards (or at least, not intentionally). What we should call the worst of the three possible outcomes (failure or completion) is a different argument.