Excuse me, but since when can manifestation of zeal be stolen??! It cannot be moved, so it cannot be stolen, right? Is this a hack of some sort? Im on an official pvp server (PC), so zero mods.
I believe the event log sometimes is just plain wrong or gets information crossed at times. I had someone accuse me of taking their stuff and dismantling their base. Their event log said I dismantled a foundation. It was certainly incorrect because when I found out where said base was located, I had never even been to that part of the map in ages, let alone even knew someone built there.