I feel once pets are fully grown they shouldn’t require food to survive. Ark made this a nightmare in the pet system. I don’t want 90% of my time hunting food for my pets. I agree food should be useful for resources gathering from pets.
I rather keep food needed for my pet survival a baby pet thing.
Is getting food really that hard for you? It requires zero effort for me to pick up feral and/or savory meat just as I go about my business. Sometimes I go on exploratory runs, and the meat I found at the beginning of the run has gone bad before I was done. Or maybe you’re concerned about the herbivores? Sure, there are vast swathes of area where there’s no plant life…but it’s not like plant fiber spoils.
TL;DR: Thralls eat food to heal, you eat food to heal…why should a pet be any different?
Pets and Thralls should require food as a way to place a soft limit to the amount of server resources used by players. Right now a solo player can bring a server to its knees by placing unlimited thralls around his base. Having to maintain some kind of food storage could fix this while adding more content to the game.
I think it’s fine that they need food, or people will hord them like many things, and fill bases with pets they never realy look at again once captured.
I think they should attack the owner if we miss to feed them, that would make sens and be fun !
We for sure need a feeding system in place for pets and thralls. It is the only way to fix the bases with 100 thralls hovering in the air and will keep people from having hordes of thralls. Totally unrealistic to have that many.
Raiding is already as easy as it can get. Thralls (when working) is the only thing that actually gives some real defenses on pvp servers. Even then it’s easy as hell to kill them, just either gas them or shoot them with arrows from a far away distance where they can’t get you.
Having a feeding system just brings unnecessary grinding to the game, brings nothing of value.
I think at first the answer is a good working AI for thralls, making them act and defend as they should. Of course if AI is failing on 2 of 3 thralls in a base, it’s easy to figure out what people will do: add more thralls.
And that isn’t the solution nor, still more thralls are not realy realistic, at least immersion-breaking, and bad for server performances. A just middle way must be found, so that people can defend theyr bases, set-up some farms in pve, but without the whole thing completely overdone.
Also experience made, to much thralls just will make them fail defending. There is certainly a bit of a perfect number per area (m2 or foundations) where they work better than crowding a place.
Food for thralls is an other story. I think it could be fine on pve-servers again, but i doubt that the game is allowing such differences one day.
Not having to eat or feed your pet makes you not have to worry about, you know, survival.
As far as food for thralls, I agree it should be a thing. The problem with this, though, is crafting thralls are not people… they are objects. I actually spoke to the Devs about this because I wanted to add armor from one of my mods to them and the Dev flat-out told me that crafting thralls have no inventory because they are an object type, not a creature. To make thralls require food would mean a complete redesign of crafting thralls. Having to feed combat thralls and not crafting thralls seems kind of pointless.
??? Feeding your dinos in Ark took no time if you had any dinos worth feeding. One outing with a high level carnivore dino and one outing with a high lev berry gathering dino. It’s at absolute worst 15 minutes of your time. Maintaining a garden solo was way worse with all the running around and manually picking up poop.
If you don’t have to do some kind of maintenance and grinding for it then your pet’s just a decoration. Especially for resource generating pets or pets with some use, needing to maintain them makes sense, and adds gameplay.
If thralls had had more of the complexity of Ark’s tames, I would most likely have stuck around longer.
Hell, just take a ride out into the swamp area for leech harvesting with a Therizno. The therizno would do all the work of getting food for your dinos in one trip plus other valuable resources and had zero chance of anything killing it.
Picking up poop wasn’t a problem either. Just get a phiomia and keep feeding it stim berries.