19% of 50 is 9. So I know math is a Lil more complex calculating damage from weapon, their armor, and your armor pen, but for arguments sake let’s say that makes your weapon 59dmg vs 53. The other weapon has like 6 dmg more so if a thrall had 200 hp both would take about 4 hits to kill to reach that 200. So while it may do more damage on certain hp npc you wouldn’t notice the difference since it would need more hits to widen the damage gap.