I’m seeing alot of references to real life, judges, and laws. So let’s make things clear.
All the notions of free speech, innocent till proven guilty, and all that are irrelevant. The Official servers are rented property. That means the customer (Funcom in this case) of that rental service has the right and privilege to govern those servers however they wish.
Its not a public space. In the public we have those aforementioned ideals because we all take part within our governments and the society as a whole. A private server (which is what an Official is, just rented by Funcom, the only difference in this regard) is not a public space.
Its open to the public (us), but we have no entitlement to be there. We choose to be there. And when we do choose to play on those servers we agree to their rules. Every official server player has agreed to follow the rules, to the letter, and adjust when the rules change. They do this upon logging in. Whether they see the rules or not. Simply logging in is agreeing to follow the rules.
But here’s the catch. Not only do you agree to follow the rules as they are written. But you agree to the rules that are unwritten in the minds of who is renting the server. And even those rules can have consequences. And the players of the Official servers have to abide by them, they agreed to. Even if they don’t know, don’t care, or whatever.
I get it, its frustrating to have ambiguous rules, rule changes that are ephemeral, and enforcement that appears inconsistent. But here’s the thing. There’s been dozens of dozens of threads about this build or that build being too big. This blocking that. And so forth. The standard for building in Conan is not easily defined. And our community here has never been able to agree with one.
I’ve played on servers that only allowed a single player to build in a 10x10 area, and go maybe 6-8 blocks tall. Servers that allow 250 building pieces total. I’ve also played on servers where I’ve been able to build things that dwarf some of the things shown in this thread. And everything inbetween.
If I posed the question, ‘how big should a player be able to go?’ You all would have different answers. Some of you might even be clever enough to say it depends on what is built and where it is built. Sure. But even then, if I took everyone who has that line thinking. They would not be able to agree on a singular standard. They might even say its case by case.
Case by case. The very definition of ambiguity.
For example, I don’t know if it was in this thread, or another. But someone admitted to building over a Black Rhino spawn. I’ve played on servers where that isn’t allowed. And it does technically restrict access to content. But the idea was that “well everyone agrees that its fine.” Just for the sake of argument, where’s this list of content the community agrees can be blocked and its ‘fine’?
I personally don’t care about a black rhino spawn. But what if someone does. Or at least claims to. What is the admin who handles the tickets submitted supposed to do? There’s no actual list of community-accepted do’s and don’ts. So the only document he has is the rules as written.
Should he enforce the rules as written, or make a call of judgment?
This is where things get problematic. Let’s not even argue about whether we agree on one or the other, because we’re not going to be able to. Let’s talk about reality.
In reality the admin is going to do both at least ideally. They’re going to check the area, and make a call. If the rhino doesn’t have any unique drops and there’s more spawns of it available on the map. Its likely they’re not going to give the player any problems. Otherwise… poof.
Now let’s dig deeper into the actual reality. That admin isn’t doing this stuff occasionally. They’re likely assigned to do this for a lot of tickets. They’re going to have to make these calls on likely several dozen reports or more.
We expect them to be 100% clear, concise, fair, and thoughtful on every incident they investigate. That’s a fantasy. On private servers where admins can literally make up 10-20% of the playerbase, we don’t expect 100%, its close, but never perfect. Now you’ve got one guy, or maybe a few, governing hundreds of servers.
Let’s just say the quality is going to lapse comparatively. Enforcement isn’t necessarily going to be perfectly consistent. But at the end of the day, you all do get what you pay for. This would be a whole different discussion if we were paying to play on those servers. But that’s a discussion for another thread (I don’t recommend it, its been discussed before and doesn’t go anywhere).