First of all, can we please get rid of the whole “necessity vs choice” thing? It’s a red herring and it’s definitely not helpful. If I suggested nerfing the XP and harvesting multiplier on PVP servers to 0.1, I could argue that you don’t really need to harvest or level up so quickly, it’s just your choice and preference.
I don’t insist on this point out of pedantry. This kind of framing is precisely the reason why so many people feel attacked by your arguments. None of us need to play this game in any specific way. We choose to do it because we find it enjoyable. When we’re discussing problems in the game, we are not discussing real life problems like not having enough money to pay the rent, we are discussing things that make playing the game less enjoyable for a certain number of players to a certain degree. The more players are affected and to a greater degree, the greater the magnitude of the problem.
When you start talking about how somebody doesn’t need to play the game a certain way, the message that comes across is “I can enjoy the game playing my way, so you don’t need to play the game your way.”
There’s a certain lack of both empathy and respect in that attitude. Empathy, because “you don’t need this” is basically FYGM. And respect, because you yourself have said that you don’t play PVE – you just started very recently as an experiment – and yet you presume to tell people with 3000+ hours of PVE experience how they should play.
I’m sorry if all this sounded harsh, but it’s starting to grate. Whenever I participate in a discussion that touches on PVP playstyle, I always try to keep in mind my lack of experience and ask a lot of questions whenever I’m unsure why people claim what they do. So please don’t take this as a personal attack, because I respect both your knowledge and your passion for this game, but you might wanna try to listen to what PVE players have to say just as much as some of us are trying to listen to what PVP players have to say.
Again, why? What’s the difference between building with 1000s of parts on me, on a thrall, or in a chest that I placed at the construction site?
This is where the inexperience shows. Again, don’t take this as a personal attack, but there’s no way you’ve built a big, carefully designed and decorated project if you think that there’s no real planning effort involved.
I can’t speak for every builder out there, but most good builders I know will first design their build in singleplayer, using admin cheats, and once we’re satisfied, we’ll farm up the resources and go build our design.
Making farming and building slower, more cumbersome and less enjoyable is not going to force people to plan any better. It’ll just make it slower and less enjoyable.