Thought maybe I’d just make a new comment instead of editing for clarity..
I should say that I’m of the opinion that players shouldn’t use the reporting system like some kind of “I think they broke a rule but not sure” repository, however. The reporting system is badly executed as is. Because of this, the way players can be and the lack of attention the game has been receiving, not to mention the previous controversies regarding the ToC, Official servers can and have suffered.
For me, the only time I would report is IF there is something that is seriously affecting me. Such as blocking uniques, hacking, exploiting, land claim griefing towards me, etc.,..
The population on Officials has waned for various reasons but I’m not going to add to the already poor system for minor issues like a bit of perceived “overbuilding”. FC has already made their stance on this a long ass time ago, “big” bases are not the problem.
There are literally players that report anything perceived as a violation and think that they’re doing a service and have admitted so. It feels more like they’re donning a cap of “server police” rather than playing the game. Recently a player posted here reporting for 1 foundation claiming its build spam to block others… which probably was more of a “I want mine” mentality.
That goes into now how the reporting system was abused for that very issue of “I want mine” in additiona to exploiting the system and rivalries. As a result, suspensions and bans affected the greater Official community.
So we can then look at personal responsibility and server harmony. Players are people and people do people things. Then adding in the instability of the game, GPortal servers and a poor reporting system, it can create animosities, perceptions and ad hoc justifications when people get what they want by using that system.
Quite a storied history on these events that I can talk and talk about. I made it a personal quest to understand the nuances of the reporting system and found quite a bit of interesting stuff. Including how scripts can turn the tide. Suffice it to say that a chunk of reporting, at least in the past, hurt everyone on Officials.
I am sure I’d be close to this again if I were actually playing. That would be on Official PVP NA but I can’t.
I think OP should dismantle their claim, go somewhere else or another server. Not because I think their claim is big but because FC has, in the past, wiped offenders and non-offenders within the same area - including cases where the victim did not appear to be doing anything wrong with evidence presented.