If you did the dungeon, maxed his alter made the claws. That mean you have it unlocked always? Or just for that game? Or that character? I did this in a offline server not online could u go to a online server and make a new character with his religion?
everything you do is linked to that save/server.
If you feel the above comment solves your question, try using the 
Resolve button on it to mark the thread as Resolved 
There are also no character transfers in case you want to know.