Your solution sounds interestingly familiar… 
Maybe some more roguish elements like lock-picks and booby traps to kill/divert intruders would make PvP a little more fun too… (With siege mechanics centered around some structures that can be built on enemy turf during the siege such as palisades and mines…)
Basic idea for how a siege works:
Step one, place one or more siege tents. (These let you place thralls and structures on enemy turf for as long as they’re up, they also double as thrall pots for distributing food to your siege thralls… Siege thralls de-spawn if you don’t keep them fed.)
Step two, place down your siege equipment(Palisades, mines, trebuchets, campfires for cooking more food, bedrolls what have you… Ideally T3 structures should be tough enough to make a siege PvP session last at least a couple of days depending on how prepared the participants are… With it being you trapping another player in their house while they try to break the siege by destroying all your siege tents)
Step 3, find and destroy all beds bedrolls and players in the besieged structure… Doing so turns the besieged structure over to the winner… (Of course the defenders can always simply grab their crap and try to flee if they feel they can’t hold the position…)