As a pvp player I see absolutely no reason to change encumbrance perks.
Your a walking piñata if somebody manages to kill you. As for taking all their loot. I usually throw Vaults down when collecting if the score is big enough. On top of that I am not gonna let you come and recollect your loot.
Never want that, but your whole dialoge was just “In PvE you HAVE a big base, in PvE you have that and that and and”.
NO. In YOUR playstyle in PvE it is like that!
But:
There you got it. My answer was only directed to that… It kinda seemed like you speak for all PvE or HOW PvE should be played…
Me too… But not everywhere Why should I decorate an outpost, where I know I will destroy in 1-2 months anyway, when I have all thralls from there…
And currently most outposts are like that. Only 2-3, which I even started to decorate, are kinda “fix” bases.
Player vs Environment = killing NPCs, etc.
PvE does not stand for “building fancy things” Because building fancy things is NOT limited to PvE. In PvP you can do the same.
Yet you write comments on HOW you play PvE and how ONE missing perk would destroy ALL OF PvE and then you say this to me?
The question is, how many would leave because of this perk being removed and how many would adept to the changes like most do with any big change (roll for example).
The removing of the perk, does not destroy anything in PvE. Some tasks gets more tedious, but not impossible…
Yeah it gets more time consuming, but guess what else is? Thrall leveling, yet PvE has 0.25 rate of PvE-C or PvP to gain XP…
To sum it up: There is NO right or wrong playstyle. People play different and thats fine.
Having the audacity to speak for all certain players and HOW such people play the game, is MY problem.
And my answer only wanted to say that (without the intent to attack you or your playstyle).
People play different. People use different perks in the game. People are doing different things to have fun.
@heaventhere This discussion wasnt even based on players want to remove it, but the Lead designer wants it to be removed or massively changed. Where as the discussion about obelsiks, was from a player and Funcom even said, they will NOT be removed.
Seriously though, removing it only makes peoples lives more miserable. Without a compelling argument that its existence makes play miserable, there is absolutely no reason to remove it.
I feel like this thread has failed, instead of discussing opinions, it has turned into a 1 side versus the other with lots of criticism towards suggestions and ideas.
Also I think it is dangerous to talk about “the majority thinks…” because it is rarely representative for the entire player base, but mostly only represent those that bothered to engage in this thread and poll.
I’m not really against quick travel(map rooms) and 5th encumbrance perks, but I am not for them either because the way they currently are is slowly degrading the overall survival experience in my opinion.
Maprooms was if I remember correctly introduced shortly before the end of early access.
The devs talked way back in early access how the map would grow in size and that they wanted to introduce mounts for faster travelling.
We all know that they at some point said they couldn’t make mounts work, but let’s for a moment imagine that they got mounts working back then, do you think they would have introduced map rooms even though?
The 5th encumbrance perk which enable you to carry any amount of overweight was introduced with the perk system before we even had high inventory capacity followers and low stack size, so it kinda made some sense back then, but still it felt a bit weird that you could have unlimited overweight and still run, it definitely not a thing in most similar survival games, and maybe for several good reasons.
The past 6-8 months they have increased the stack size for several items and most common resources used for building have increased from 100 to 1000.
I mean… Come on people, I have very little understanding for those that call a possible removal or nerf of this perk for game breaking, because people were gathering resources just fine before all these buffs to transporting stuff.
I understand why Alex doesn’t like this perk because in my opinion it is too overpowered and in some weird way makes transportation and building way too easy.
As an example I was bored on the pve-c server I played on, so I decided to build a little monument on the same spot where my very first base had been.
I had some resources to get started maybe 10-20% of what was needed, so I grabbed my T4 bearer thrall and went out to harvest(and no I hadn’t spec’ed for 5th encumbrance perk), after an unknown amount of trips I felt that I had enough to build my little monument/base, that took most of a day perhaps 6-8 hours.
I spent maybe 2 more days building + decorating and when it was finished I felt proud of my accomplishment, but also a bit weird that I could put such a huge up in such a short time built totally in T3 with lots of details and decoratives.
As a final word, I am mostly a pve player that like exploring, fighting and building, I’ve been here almost from the beginning of early access and while I think that the game has improved in many ways, it also has decreased in others, mostly it has lost its bite in certain areas… Some things have just gotten too easy.
Polls about nerfs often gets more attention from people that are against it than ok with it, it was probably the same when they told us that they would add map rooms for fast travel, a lot of people back then worried that it would make the world seem a lot smaller, in my opinion it did, but I got used to it.
Getting used or attached to things is often dangerous, if we look back it has mostly been updates that made certain aspects easier like fx our options for transportation where we got Map rooms, pets, bearers, perk system and lately a huge increase in stack size, I mean with the 5th encumbrance perk we can carry an entire base with stations and working thralls in our inventory… I find this a bit crazy and over the top while others find it good and necessary to avoid so-called “game breaking” grind.
I know people have different opinions on this and that is ok with me, you can try to convince me otherwise, but I have felt that every changes that made things easier was just welcomed, but when they tried to balance by changing or removing something, some people then start protesting that it will make the game too hard or almost unplayable.
I also sometimes do that, but sometimes taking a deep breath and look at the bigger picture helps to see why, also it would help if Funcom explain better why they want to change something
If they don’t want me to carry everything then give me a wagon I can attach to the back of my Horse/Rhino/Elephant to haul stuff around in large chests etc…I would love to go back to combat spec full time.
Never the intent. I have only ever spoken for myself and I am sorry for the misunderstanding, but I don’t know why anyone would assume otherwise.
When I talk about PvE in a more generalized sense then just myself, it isn’t to talk for all PvE players or people that don’t want me talking for them.
Its done in reference to the ‘building community’, people that play the game like I do, are out there and are significant number of players. This is proven via my own anecdotal experience, friends that build like I do, an entire server I was part of building and playing similar to I do, forum posts from many posters expressing the same interest, as well as countless steamers/youtubers that play the game primary just for building.
It was a sweeping statement because there are in fact a lot of us (many that I would guess make heavy use of the 5th enc perk). It wasn’t a sweeping statement to encompass all ideologies. I don’t know who would be so ignorant and narcissistic to do such.
I wasn’t criticizing your way of playing. I am just stating that the 5th enc perk directly effects and facilitates this type of game time. Removing it would heavily handicap this type of game time. Just because you found a way of not using the specific perk that makes you happy, doesn’t mean its the same for the many with opposing thoughts on this issue.
I know what PvE stands for smarty pants…
But I think you are misconstruing the meaning. PvE simply means that I am playing the game, against the game, not competitively against another player.
That has 0 to do with how I play the game. PvE includes building fancy things, as well as anything else you decide to do. So once again, I don’t understand you point in this statement. I play PvE just as accurately and correctly as you do (as would the extreme example of someone that just wanted to join the game and nakedly run around the map for their entire game time, doing nothing else. Its not like the PvE label has some specific qualifications players have to meet to claim thats what their playing… That just doesn’t make any sense.
Yes, because they are entirely different situations.
I am using my game time, and claiming evidence of other players playing like me as a defense to a request of a removal of a mechanic me and mine all enjoy.
You are trying to use your game time as a qualification as to why my stance ‘doesn’t matter’.
Im saying many players use the perk, including myself, therefor its’ removal would be detrimental.
You are saying that because you enjoy the game without the perk, others should be able to as well.
Do you see the difference there? Completely different situations and context. Both experiences in game carry the same weight, have the same value. I am not a more important player then you. However, I am defending a stance using my game time as evidence as why I, and others wouldn’t like its removal.
What you enjoy in game yourself isn’t a logical argument as to why our reasoning for keeping the perk isn’t valid.
Me using my game time and what I enjoy as a defense of the mechanic doesn’t devalue your game time or cast any shade on you.
You stating ‘that since you can enjoy the game without the perk, others should be able to as well’, does devalue other players game time. It is you criticizing how others play.
Thats not the question at all.
Keeping the perk wont make anyone quit the game (I’d argue if it does, it would be because this was the final straw and you have other criticisms as well. I highly doubt anyone would quit because it stays.) However, many would quit if it was removed and not adequately replaced (myself included). As Funcom is a business, and business is typically about money. I would argue the safer bet is the scenario where people don’t leave the game.
I don’t agree with you at all. When the tedious grinding tasks outweigh the enjoyable parts of a game, the game becomes unplayable. I enjoy building (among other things) in this game, not farming and supply trips.
A game design change to increase the time investment to unenjoyable parts and decrease the enjoyable parts not only seems bass ackwards, but would destroy PvE (once again, for many of us. You need to stop thinking about your own personal experience).
You bring up thrall leveling doesn’t support your cause. I stopped thrall leveling after my 3rd thrall. Its so mind numbingly boring, I stopped doing it. Its a part of the game that just happens slowly and naturally for me when I farm cities/bosses, because actively doing it is like drilling holes in my brain.
Are you suggesting the game should be designed similarly to the same thought process of the mind numbing activity of leveling thralls? Because its so fun? I don’t think many would agree with you.
This is what I was stating from the start, and is one of my primary reasons for defending the 5th encumbrance perk. I never talked for ‘everyone’, I never have, never will, nor did I ever indicate that I was. Its easiest to refer to a big group of PvE players when I refer to ‘in PvE’. Never in my mind did that equate to a sweeping statement for all players.
On the flip side, while you didn’t intend to attack my play styles, comments like “Ridiculously big building with not really any purpose” is a direct attack on people that play the game like I do. We build big and focus on design because its what we like to do. That is our play style, and what we have found in this game to invest in. You stating it has no purpose is a direct disqualification and discredit of how we play. So maybe you want to rethink that one.
Many people here are indeed asking for its removal with absolutely no thought to their fellow players that enjoy the game differently.
Farming it would make more irritating and longer. There is no reason for this.
Building is where the removal would be a major problem. Increase stack size doesn’t solve the problem. I dont know a single person in this forum that could argue with a straight face that running back and forth between your project and a box for supplies is enjoyable. This is why it’d be game breaking. Game breaking in the sense that the work in the game outweighed the enjoyment.
I fully understand the problem are referring to when they talk about either the travel or the enc mechanics. I am not dismissing them. However, those problems seem trivial to the problems created from their removal.
In PvE, this is a survival game for the first 40 levels or so (you could even argue up to 60), but at 60 it isn’t any more. You survived. The game needs to provide other enjoyment at that point. Many of us went to building to fill the game in game direction. These mechanics don’t trivialize the survival aspect of this game. Hitting level 60 and the entire game design trivializes the survival aspect of this game.
removing these mechanics is a false conclusion for a solution that wouldn’t work.
It was great to hear about your personal experience or not having the need of that perk. But as I was stating to Jot, thats anecdotal. That is your own experience. Your ability to get it up so fast was because you were end level and prepared. Long past the survival part of this game.
This isn’t the same experience while leveling and actually in the situation where you have to survive.
If you want to change this game to be a survival game for the full experience, the best bet is PvP. As making end game, lvl 60, survival a heavy aspect of this game, Funcom would pretty much have to completely redesign how things work at 60. I don’t think thats ever going to happen.
The removal of mechanics many players use wont solve the problem. It’ll just make Funcom’s player numbers go down.
I am all for the removal of bad systems. But of course players will speak out against the removal of a widely used system.
I have yet to see a single person yet counter the fact that its continued inclusion has minimal impact and effect on the game, vs. its removal would be heavily detrimental to how many people play.
This hasn’t been answered once. People opposed only side step the statement saying something along the lines of ‘Well, I don’t play that way, so obviously that must be a exaggeration.’ and all that is is a dismissal and avoidance to the actual point.
Irrelevant. I use it a lot and swap back and forth a lot (I keep enough materials for >50 beastial memories at a time). My current base has >100k stone sunk in it in the form of hard brick, so yes, removal would impact my play greatly. As I pay for my own server and my server mates also make use of the perk, removing it would impact us. If there is a compelling reason to remove it based on environment, I can see arguing it be a server option (enable/disable lvl 5 enc perk) and pvp officials could duke it out amongst themselves, but there’s no reason to drag other servers into those desires.
I agree that the thread has failed, although I don’t think it’s because of criticism towards suggestions and ideas, but rather because the discussion of opinions has turned into a polarized argument about irrelevant semantic quibbles and other topics.
Yeah, that’s one of those “other topics” I was referring to. Somehow the whole issue of map rooms got dragged into this discussion.
Unless we’re proposing a server wipe and a massive rework of all the game mechanisms – basically reworking the game into something different and restarting it for everyone – then the whole “but they wouldn’t have introduced map rooms if they had mounts” is moot.
This is the game we’re playing now and we’re discussing the balance of it and how certain changes might impact it. I know it would have been a very different game if they had just developed it differently. To quote Gino D’Acampo, “if my grandmother had wheels, she would have been a bike.”
It all depends on your definition of “game breaking”. I happen to agree with you – removing the perk wouldn’t be game breaking, just as having the perk isn’t game breaking.
However, there’s plenty of shades of gray between “everything’s fine” and “the game is broken”. Yes, people were gathering resources before all these buffs. I was one of those people and I don’t want to go back to that unless: 1) having those buffs is causing serious problems, and 2) there is no better solution for those problems.
This should be easy to understand and accept. If I suddenly said “we should get rid of explosive jars and make raids rely on trebuchets”, everyone would expect me to provide better arguments than “it’s too easy to raid with explosives”, “if you have trebuchets, you shouldn’t need explosive jars” or “but what if they never implemented explosive jars and made us use trebuchets right from the start”.
Personally, I don’t understand why Alex doesn’t like this perk, because he hasn’t even come close to giving his own reasons.
I do agree that making transportation and building “too easy” can be a problem, but nobody has even touched that particular point in the last 100+ messages. Instead, we have two groups, one trying to “prove” that removing the perk is not detrimental to anyone, the other latching onto that and trying to offer rebuttals.
I wouldn’t mind continuing the discussion of why easy building and transportation are detrimental and how that can be solved, with or without perk removal
I apologize for my part in any derailing. However, it felt like 1 single rebuttal that I followed with more posts then I wanted to make, trying to explain myself as almost every response implied misunderstanding. I probably should have never started with the rebuttable against something I saw as illogical as it sort of was the source of things spiraling out.
Discussing this point as the soul source of contention with the perk, it still seems like entirely a PvP issue (not belittling, but to me, clearly is on just one side of the court).
I don’t understand at all how a factor of how fast a person can either farm basic supplies during the mind numbing farm of rock and wood, or how much a person can carry while building in their specific location effects another PvE player at all, in any way.
I fully acknowledge I may be missing a point, but I haven’t seen a legitimate one brought up here yet. Only thing we have got so far are personal opinions about how people feel about the perk, not actually anything detrimental that it does to the game.
(the closest we got is the negating of the survival aspect, however, I don’t think this point holds any water as the enc perk is only a minor fraction of that problem, and removing the perk would have no effect on it what-so-ever).
On the PvP side of this, I can actually see legitimate arguments, however the problem appears minor from this side of the board. Requesting its’ removal is major for us.
It seems like the absolute easiest solution (if individual server settings could be done) would simply change how the enc perk works in a PvP environment. Maybe make it specific to if you are flagged for PvP, having the enc perk is virtually crippling in a fight. Like you can’t do combos, roll, or other specific action. (I don’t know if the game would treat a PvP flag differently from someone fighting NPC, however, the PvP dual flags give me indication there is).
This would make it easier to catch runners in a PvP server, as well as discourage people to use the perk when a fight is looming. It wouldn’t effect the PvE player base as they would only hit this situation with a dual flag and who cares about someone foolishly getting into a dual in full enc spec?
However, in the PvE environment, I would say the perk is already pretty crippling. You give up power needed for quicker fights, you give up agility and mobility, you give up the ability to counter harsh weather, and more. The perk seems entirely harmless to the PvE environment with regards to how it effects other players, and I don’t see why it would ever bother another PvE player as they could just chose to not use it.
outside of a specific PvP flag that could effect the perk to hinder its use in PvP, maybe make it so the enc perk makes players extremely vulnerable to other players? Would have a similar effect as above.
Two solutions that could potentially curb the problem without removing something many people enjoy using.
I lean more towards solutions that solve the problems the perk may cause then removing the perk and replacing it with something else as:
A. I don’t see us getting a equivalent and that would mean no matter what, the change would be annoying someone.
B. I don’t like the ‘other solutions’ proposed so far. A better bearer pack would need to be a lot better (including not blocking vision while wearing it in 3rd person. Better bearers or pack animals would mean they could never be so stupid to kill themselves or put themselves in harms way, as they do constantly currently, not to mention better slots and more functionality).
C. limiting inventory slots doesn’t solve any issue as it will essentially be just another flavor of removing the perk.
That said, I am not opposed to a replacement being the solution. However, I have yet to see an actual suggestion of a valid replacement.
So you are on a private server. You do know there is a setting that will reduce the effects of encumberance, thus you don’t even need the 5th perk. All my ideas are tied directly to officials, where the map should be shared, and thus have more restrictions on making things as easy as they currently are. Obelisks could/should be an option as well for privates to turn off currently.
I own a server. Problem is i can’t actually partake, as i am the owner, and it is PVP based, thus i remove as much of the “abuse” reasoning by not participating other than build for others to raid for fun.
Here are the GPORTAL settings, i am sure they are in the .ini files to tweak. Don;t knwo which way is which to increase/decrease effects.
PlayerEncumbranceMultiplier=1
PlayerEncumbrancePenaltyMultiplier=1
I did, like my third post. My original post never called a play style as “wrong”. It suggested we may be missing some great lore style game play because of them. The attacks started, and i got heated. But if somewhere (i don’t see it) that i said playing that way was “wrong”, that was never my intention. My intention was to state that I believe Alex sees this as hurting the economy structure of the game ( i would have to look thru the video, but he does talk about both in the last stream in December, just don’t know if they are tied together for him as they are for me). Whether he does or not, the more I (as in me and my opinion) have been on PVP servers, the more I see the economy is the sole decider in Alpha v RIP clans. To me, by having the 5th ENC, it makes that balance even wider, as well as the ability to port as close to your enemy as possible, and not march towards war if they didn’t have quick port. I literally am looking at how far those 2 can pull the player base from the lore of the mechanics. I also decided, not to prove a point, but to experience and practice what i was preaching, decided to test a PVE official and the style i envision without the perk or quick travel. On top of that, i threw in another thought of do i really even need to travel the map to build a legitimate purge-proof base? That’s it. But somehow i became the messenger of death with Funcoms ear for changes. Which it was the case, then i would definitely do some things different.
You do realize if I do that, EVERYONE has that right? The goal is not to GIVE AWAY the perk for free; that involves relegating encumbrance as immaterial and now everyone tanks up. Are you seriously offering that as an option or just trolling?
Yeah, it’s one of the things I thought of and proposed on certain occasions: while the building damage is enabled, make it impossible to teleport while overencumbered and have overencumbered players receive no protection from their armor.
From what I recall, the solution wasn’t deemed good enough, because people can still come up laden with a whole bunch of stuff and set up an outpost really quickly: all the building pieces, all the necessary ingredients and crafting stations.
Of course, I don’t really understand this line of reasoning, because to fix this “problem”, you would have to completely neuter everything related to building and transportation. Get rid of the 5th perk and a clan of 3 can still set up their outpost in the same short timeframe.
For your private, where you say the players you play with use it and need it, then yes. As it would just remove the need to respec to the 5th ENC and allow everyone to flip to farm even quicker and save even more time.
Don’t take my reply to Frillen as accusation or finger-pointing. If I had wanted to place blame, I would’ve combed the whole thread and quoted the exact post where things somehow went wrong. Except that I don’t believe that can be done – there’s rarely one person and one post – and I don’t think it adds anything to do so
You don’t do that. You do have a habit of saying things along the lines of “it’s PVE, take your time”. I generally take it in good faith and offer my counterargument to that, but there are probably others who will feel like they’re being attacked or marginalized by that
Yes, Alex talked about how the economy needs to be reworked, although I think that was in a different stream. In his controversial remark about the 5th enc perk, he didn’t state his reasons for disliking the perk, just that he would like to change it because it’s bad for the game.
I’ve been visiting that part of the video very often – I even linked it in my initial post here – in order to make sure I’m not missing something he said
There are two points here. The first one is the effect of the 5th enc perk on the economy, but I don’t really understand it. Perhaps you can clarify, but to me it seems that nerfing the farming ability of everyone will just give more power to the alpha clans. If you have an alpha clan and you’ve set yourself up strategically, the farming nerf should hurt your clan much less than anyone who intends to challenge you, right?
As for the map rooms giving you the ability to port close to your enemies, I fail to see how that’s a huge problem. Granted, the closer you are to an obelisk, the easier it is to attack you. Is that really it? Because once your base is a certain distance from an obelisk, attacking you is practically the same with or without map rooms.
Again, this is not an outright dismissal of your arguments, but rather a request for clarification
Yeah, people like to exaggerate. FWIW, I’m sorry if you’re feeling attacked and frustrated, and I value your input, regardless of whether I agree with you or not.
I can’t do much except trying to keep my end of the discussion as reasonable as I can, but I do hope you don’t just give up and stop posting here. It’s precisely people like you whose input I was interested in when I created the thread, because after all this time, I still fail to understand what makes the 5th enc perk so detrimental. And believe me, I really have been trying.
Yah, i agree. I see the point and the argument, but I have yet to see anyone correctly connect the removal of the perk to a successful solution.
Removing the perk just doesn’t do what so many are claiming it would do. It would potentially have a minimal effect on the problems people are stating they are having with the perk, however the problem would still be prevalent. Meanwhile, removing it would cause many many more problems that are not given much credit by many.
The solution should actually fix the problems raised, not have minimal effect and cause more problems. But removal and every suggesting I have seen from the opposition does exactly that.
If you are misunderstanding something, I am as well.
As it sounds like ‘how fast someone can set up for attack’ or ‘how fast someone can grab stuff and run away’ are truly the issues and not the perk itself, how about critical items, such as explosives just ignore the perk’s attribute and weigh calculated amounts to control how powerful an attacking force is?
No one is going to raid a base with building supplies, and I don’t know about others, but I don’t build with explosives (my treb for looks and fun wouldn’t be handicapped by this change either).
It sounds like the problem isn’t the perk, but how quickly it enables people launch a surprise powerful attack. Decisions around this would need to be made carefully, as I would think a surprise attack is a valid means of PvP in this game.
What about a clan wide explosive cool down mechanic? Like a specific number of explosives can be used in a specific amount of time before it hits a global cool down and the clan has to rely on other raiding mechanics?
There has got to be a way to actually focus on solving the problem without creating more issues or dumping on what I would imagine to be at least half the player base.
I don’t know about that yet. There are people who claim the perk makes attackers OP. There are people who claim it makes defenders OP. There are people who claim that you simply shouldn’t be able to build a fortress in a day. I’m still not sure what people actually think.
I don’t expect a consensus, of course. But I’m still too damn confused and it’s frustrating, given how much people have written