That thing about Internet: people often dont need a reason to complain, but just an excuse.
It is like the “Classic thing” on WoW. NO ONE would want servers that worked and felt like Vanilla WoW. Most people talking “big game” were the ones who started playing in the boom of WotLK when ads like these were around and everyone and their moms were playing WoW:
And that was the time most things retail Legion still had about it. It was a couple months before the first LFG was introduced, I know, but everything else was just the way it would function from then on.
WoW vanilla was a mess. People were writing the same arguments you see here about it then. Saying they should “roll back updates”, the game was “unplayable”, etc etc.
WoW classic was, like said repeatedly, the WoW of late WotLK remade to resemble the same levels (what people call maps) of vanilla, but completely different from what vanilla WoW actually functioned.
People who ask CE to be like it was are incurring in the same “disconnected from reality mess”.
The guy is making some of the same stupid points people make to this day, like “not procedurally generated”, when EVERY SINGLE game since 2000s are always procedurally generated characters, levels, etc. As people dont seem to know things designed by hand, or scanned (like rocks for example) still then procedurally enhanced and assembled like a IKEA furniture, procedually. But anyways, then there is the “whole jab” after around 2:53 on the video.
I am dead sure I would not like the game to be back that way, or anything near it. I am sure I dont want “Siptah time CE” as well.
It is very hard to believe someone who has played this game even 2 years ago would want it to be like it was at that time, imagine “when paid for years ago”, which in many cases is over 4 years.
As people still stuck on WoW’s “meme”, “You think you do, but you dont/ We actually did”, which is a dumb lie. Same with most people talking about “back in the day” regarding games.
Very few games are worse after updates than they were at launch, and CE is not one of them. That is a objective fact.