I’ve done 1200 damage with a Katana prior to Siptah (2.0). You can’t do that now.
Interesting. So they really just were slaves to the “meta” without actually doing their own investigation?
1 Like
In this case they didn’t even read the patch notes.
But in either case, the attack in question is pretty unreliable in most situations, which is why I don’t use it. Its great for clearing out a large pull in New Asgarath and getting a giggle, but not much else. Or as a nasty surprise to someone who doesn’t know it exists. A single bit of damage is going to interrupt the combo, which is why I don’t use the weapon myself anymore.
3 Likes
I havent used much katana that’s true. But still knew the moveset of it.
And since it’s more common now that people uses it’s more easier to see that the damage is a problem. Doesnt matter if it’s been like this for 1 day or 10 years, it’s still a problem.
Pretty crazy if you did 1200 dmg back then, and didnt see it as a problem.
1 Like
Lol what are you talking about? I think everyone knew the moveset. It’s was there in 2.8 aswell, and before that like you said. But it didnt came up as a problem untill now.
Also by your explanation how to use it just proofs you dont know @#€% about combat tbh. Lmao " Its great for clearing out a large pull in New Asgarath and getting a giggle, but not much else"
No because the TTK to do that was too high. Hitting someone with a trebuchet rock does quite a bit more than 1200 on a direct hit too, but its too difficult to pull off in real world conditions.
Maybe I should amend that to include incompetence.
unreliable and extremely situational.
oh the irony…
What? You could pretty much use any weapon type for PVE stuff.
Considering the topic, they’re going to need more than a year. 
1 Like
Go play PVP and you will understand that 90% of it is PVE related 
Dude, your toxicness in this forums suprises me. Calling people dumb and incompetent probably makes you feel better. You wanna know what? I dont care.
Like I said earlier I would loved to see all these anti spear guys cry if this was about the spear instead
What changed hmmm let me think the entire attribute system and strength being bad in it?
I guarantee the things I have said in this thread are tame even by PVE-C global chat standards. Let’s not play the victim card when you get called out on a 4 year old mechanic.
1 Like
Their favorite youtuber hasn’t posted that video yet.
1 Like
Im not playing a victim. Just suprises me how toxic you are overall
Who is that?
No offense… but I think you may be suffering from a mild-to-moderate case of superiority complex here… you should get that checked out!
Even other PvP players in this thread are trying to be productive and have a discussion while you’re there trying to ridicule and trigger people acting like the “pvp bigshot”. If you’re truly THAT good then surely you don’t need to whine about a lousy katana, right?
Something about pots and kettles here…
This is the type of attitude that will trigger people and simply result in the thread getting locked.
It’s not about that and nobody is “anti-spear”, we just recognize that the people calling for this change are primarily spear users… and they are not bothered for example by the range of the spear being outrageous to where no other weapon can even get close to them to do damage… but they’re suddenly complaining about the one thing that can “occasionally” get to them by luck… through a dash…
And the information is cherry picked and staged… like I said… the presentation video in the OP is literally positioned to do maximal damage… a few steps in either direction and it would do half the damage, it probably took them quite a few tries to record it like this…
Furthermore like others tried to point out… this is not a “one-button” oneshot kill… it requires a setup… you need to do a full combo that has another action mixed into it, so it’s not something you do with mindless button mashing. A setup that can be interrupted… even the attack is linear… cannot be auto-locked or focused and you can literally side-step and avoid it…
So the counter to this is to keep your eyes open when you see someone with a katana…
3 Likes
Look in my history. I have complained about duping. Reason you dont see it is because most of those threads getting closed and unlisted pretty fast.
I seek balance where atleast some weapons dont deal x3-x4 damage than other weapons.
No because u know what? That’s the only advantage spear has against other weapons.
1 Like
Yea, but it’s a pretty big one won’t you agree? Like… you can’t talk about the advantages of other weapons when they can never even get in range to be used
Nah not really since you have the disadvantage that you actually need to aim to hit with spear.
All other weapons will outdamage spear any day kinda.