Beastmaster Teimos broken! balance?

Yes, I agree do not nerf. Instead I would say buff the other thralls.

Can you give me a thrall name, that is good as well? I want to do some tests.

Naming and shaming not allowed maybe the reason for the lack of disclosed names ?

Tell me, is it easier, to buff all the top slaves, or change, for example, the% chance of teimos spawning from 50% to 4, for example? Which is easier, to work on a bunch of slaves, or on one?

Easier would not provide balance though possibly . Better to be sure to do it right and make sure there is atleast a few foes for everyone to keep it interesting in my opinion.

I have an army of teimos on a pvp server. This only suggests that the previously top slaves after the nerf have become much weaker than him. I have no choice, why would I take weak slaves? Dalinsia? Or slaves from the Chimerian purge who were top before the nerf, if there is a smelly teimos?
It is not necessary to nerf his characteristics, you can just make him a fighter from the purge, or make him a small percentage of spawn. It shouldn’t be so easy for the players to get the strongest slave, that’s all.

Just looking at hidden modifiers:

Fighters: Ceimmerian Berserker, Dalinsia Snowbringer, Relic Hunter Treasure Seekers, and all the Votaries 4 variants

Archers: Markos Bane of Beasts, Lisa O’ the Longbow, Mandighai Hundred-Arrow, and all the VotAries 4 variants. (Many more than this bc Tiemos has a lower Ranged Dmg multiplier)

Most if not all of these have similar starting HP to Tiemos.

The most recent formula to calculate thrall damage I can find is :
(MDM/RDM * % Bonus Melee/Ranged) + (MDM/RDM * Weapon Damage) + Armor Penetration = Damage Output

That means that hidden multipliers and weapon Dmg are the biggest contributors to what thralls can output. I do think that identical thralls pitted against one another, where one is STR trained and the other is VIT, VIT tend to be victorious.

Interested in seeing what your testing reveals!

Personally I feel Beastmaster Teimos is fine the way he is now. Not spawning every time, easy to level up and get a chance to be highest hp thrall.
On a off chance he get perk that reduce Vit, he get hit harder compare to the other thrall.
So to me he is a unstable thrall that is more likely become an archer but being a fighter pay off is great.
Beside this way it become a mind game between the old and new pvp player of the server.
Will the old player try to interrupt new player recruiting process or new player let the old player waste time at the Beastmaster Teimos spawn area?

Your whole post is great, thank you. Omitting STR and AGI what some people keep leaving out is PvP has status effects, and SURV will save a lower-vit thrall. I find Teimos to be underwhelming, except for how cool he looks when you fight him as an NPC.

@Ulyssi beat me to it and was much more thorough. I wouldn’t have remembered to pick the archers and would’ve just gone with Dalinisia, Cimmerian Zerker, RHTS and the Votaries.

With how easy it is to get poison weapons on IoS I have seriously reconsidered how valuable SUR can be. I would love to see data on the effects of SUR vs VIT in regards to time to kill with DoTs.

Unfortunately there isn’t many PvP players in here, and they are certainly not the ones attempting to debase the argument. At least not without actually testing first.

However, like usual there is a lot of PvE players dogpiling a PvP player who feels there is an imbalance in the game.

That’s not to say OP is right, or wrong. But there is a reason that a lot of people are using Teimos. Admittedly the same could be said about the Berserkers, or DSH etc.

So does Teimos need to be nerfed? In my opinion, not really.

That’s because;

  • Anyone can easily get a Teimos.
  • There are other guaranteed T4 spawns, you can usually farm multiples of in the time it takes to get a Teimos.

So for me, there is some balance in obtaining BMT vs other viable T4. That doesn’t really prove OP wrong, it’s just an opinion based on my own play style.

However, Teimos actually has a 75% spawn rate, (I’m not sure where OP got 50%). He levels very fast, and considering the points per level in vit being high, and the melee dmg modifier being only negligably lower (0.16%) than most decent slow levelling T4s, it does give some weight to OPs argument.

Obviously he will be no match for actual players in PvP so it’s not really a “git gud” situation as much as I enjoy hearing you all say that. :joy:

As this has been brought up several times at this point, I doubt the devs see an issue with it, or it would have definitely been addressed by now.

But I wish you guys would rethink the way you approach these topics sometimes. Try to give a balanced reason for your arguments, instead of defaulting to saying people are salty, or crying etc.

Very much worthy of testing. What I do mean is Teimos vs another Fighter with a different SUR multiplier. I think head to head, SUR Teimos dies to VIT Teimos.

I am a dirty PvPer. I’ve seen a few other people who I think are PvPers too chime in - in opposition.

It’s a bad argument to begin with. Teimos is one of the best farmable thralls. For reasons people have already listed. If you change that some other thrall just takes his place (RHTS IMO). It’s Cimm Zerkers on IoS for example.

Teimos is not the best combat thrall in the fighter or archer categories for PvP. I listed better ones.

He has big VIT bonuses, but that matters only after the player using him is dead. No good PvPer is prioritizing killing thralls with 10k hp over the player with 600. Thralls that hit harder are FAR more dangerous to PvPers than ones with needlessly high hp - especially with how fast paced engagements are now.

With DoT weapons? If so that is a very interesting data point.

Edit: You brought up AGI too, I’ve seen some interesting math on the returns of stacking AGI. It doesn’t seems like it is worth it at a certain point, but % mitigation is so strong barring the rampant DoTs

Since I’m one of those PVE players “dogpiling” the OP, I’ll give you my views on this.

When someone comes onto the forums with a claim that something is unbalanced, the burden on proof is on them. They should be the one to back up their claim with solid arguments. If they don’t do it, then I might do it for my counterarguments, but I don’t have to. I often do it anyway, but I don’t really have as much time as I used to have, and I’m tired of people demanding nerfs without doing their own due diligence.

I don’t call people “salty” or say that they’re “whining” or “crying” or many other personal attacks I’ve seen so far. However, I will call people out on not being willing to back their claims with solid argument or change their minds when presented with arguments they can’t counter.

So yeah, I agree that personal attacks are not cool. But I don’t quite agree with the rest. Just as much as you wish the rest of us would rethink our approach, I wish people who start topics would rethink theirs, too.

If it walks like a duck, quacks like a duck. . . . its usually a duck.

Some people like to discuss and argue a point to death, some of us just cut to the chase.

I am pretty sure the PVE (C) community is very sick and tired of wannabe PVPers crying nerf after 4 + years.
Fact: Everything affects all players.
Fact: The majority of PVP salt never uses this forum until they get wrekked, then they show up with tears crying nerf. The OP is a good example. 10 months later. . . . lol.
Fact: Assuming people that now play PVE have never played PVP makes an ass of u and me.

Teimos is an obvious and uncontested imba in the matter of choosing the best fighter and even more so an archer on a server of any format. But it doesn’t matter - almost any T4 thrall with good equipment and average leveling is enough to clear all PvE content alone and make PvP players ignore themselves.
The slave and pet system has gone too far. They have become too powerful and useful. Ride your horse and command your terminator - or be a wimp.
I really miss the old days, when slaves died from any fall and could not cope with a couple of wolves. The player had to be the hero himself. Now everything is done by slaves… Tugra needs a little help. Berserker - sometimes feed and rest. And Teimos - just a little practice on the monkeys from the jungle.

I think thrall strength becomes hard to quantify at high tiers. I haven’t personally seen anything in this thread that makes me feel like he’s far enough out of line with other top thralls to merit weakening him.

A solo PvP fight is going to come down to which player kills the other faster, and then the player and his thrall will murder even a extremely high health thrall

The best argument I’ve seen as a way to “balance” BTM is to make his spawn more rare than it currently is. But I don’t think that’s really necessarily, after all while your getting you BMT I can get Berserkers, often more than one in a single mounds run and have a chance at another top tier thrall

I don’t like the idea of buffing all thralls to his level either though. I wouldn’t mind if some of the weaker T4s were improved, but I don’t feel there needs to be complete parity between all T4s.

I feel like it would be beneficial all around if we stop deciding why other players are asking for a change. We don’t know them, or their experience. Assuming they are just noobs who got beat by something is needlessly belittling.

If you agree with their idea support it, if you don’t argue against it. But please try to focus on the game and proposed changes, not the player or what you think their motivations might be.

So am I, and I’m also in opposition for the reasons I stated.
But that doesn’t mean we are right just because we play PvP.
Nor does it mean that people should attack the OP for having an opinion that’s different to ours.

I know that, and you are typically always someone who relies on evidence, or balanced arguments. That’s why you are in my top liked users.

However, no matter how someone approaches a topic what goes on in some of these threads is just wrong, and unnecessary.

Honestly JJdancer I love your witty sarcasm (genuinely) just as much as the next forum user does, but sometimes… :joy:


Anyways thanks to everyone dogpiling me now. I was just asking you guys to show a fellow human a little civility in these uncertain times, it really brings joy to my heart. :heart: :joy:


Wait, I don’t know if you are agreeing with me, or…

It was meant in the opposite way. So everyone please forgive me if it came across like that. It was an observation, certainly not a dismissal of your opinions.

Everyone should have a chance to express their thoughts, as you say there is one game, and we are all part of the same community.

Some things may be more apparent to PvP players, such as OP claws (don’t start :joy:). Other things may be more apparent to PvE players, like stage pieces losing stability.

I just don’t like it when I enter a topic and people are just throwing personal insults, and blaming PvPers for every nerf in the game etc. Unfortunately I am seeing this happen almost daily, which is just sad.


Couldn’t agree more, pretty much sums up my sentiment perfectly.

Life is hard! This game, and forum are a small escape from the “new” daily reality for most of us.

We should all try to treat each other with respect, and make this an inviting place for everyone to discuss issues that they feel are important to the game.