It is really sad that you have to cheat to win in PVP. Agreed?
Yes. I know of a clan that said they will cheat in order to stay alpha. But, as Funcom says, fix the exploit instead of the exploiter.
We’ve waited.
If these changes make RPers better PVPers and the real top dogs are now afraid of being defeated by them, then they were never good players at all! 
Lol there’s more pvp on role play servers than there is on normal pvp servers. This whole rp, pve bashing and insulting going on from a few select inane pvp players is hilarious. Bunch of children lashing out cause someone took your toy. Grow up.
To be honest it is very early for me to have opinion . Ofcurce I find it a little annoying not to be able to heal in fight , but the greatest monster I have to fight here is my habit . The game right now for me is difficult it looks different but at the same time is challenging and for me this is the most important . I waited these changes a lot , I wanted them a lot ,so I can only be glad about them . My vote went to the 3rd option because I didn’t play the game that much to have a stronger opinion about it .
Its been implied that they are going to get wrecked by a person who just bought and installed the game less than 3 days ago at least 50% of the time. That someone nearly fresh off the cross will have an even chance against anyone on a server.
Hey, I have an idea! Maybe PVE players could get snotty and elitist about the superior farming techniques that we’ve perfected and use that to look down on anyone talking about changes that impact PVE. Imagine how fun it would be to say something like “you mean you can’t get 40k stone in under 20 minutes? why are you even posting about PVE, go back to your PVP server, you don’t belong here” 
Offhand canceling was bad, wielding unwielding was good and makes the combat more fluid and fun I guess, but tbh I don’t mind this changes. Everything is just like it was a month ago, you nerfed horses but now footmen are stuck on animations, so, I guess it’s all on the same page.
snort You havent even seen my stockpile of sticks. Its sooooo big and pointy. You wish you had this many sticks. Most people go for dry wood, but those are noobs.
You’d be surprised at what pvp players can farm. if anything we HAVE to find the most efficient ways because we may actually lose our mats even when stockpiled in vaults.
But I agree, name-calling is useless. PVPers who chastise pve and rp are fooling themselves tbh.
This is reminding me of going to my clan’s ore chest and seeing 36,000 Star Metal Ore. ■■■■■■■■ Siptah… I swear Star Metal is more common than Iron.
I think people need to come up better alternatives to combat which not only makes more balance / fairer and make various weapon types useful. Then hope Funcom can implement the idea if they are reasonable of course.
And you would be surprised just how far people will go to optimize their farming if they don’t have to worry about being ganked by other players ![]()
But that’s all beside the point. We agree 100% on the important stuff:
Honest question: have you seen a single non-PvPer complain about animation canceling before this update?
In PvE, the whole feature didn’t matter. NPCs and bosses didn’t whine on the forums that they got pwned by unfair tactics.
Yeah, me.
The changes are not limited to PvP, they impact PvE as well. The people who have been most affected are the ones who use 2-handed weapons. 1-handed weapons recover from their attacks in like a quarter second or less, it feels nearly instant so there was never a need for them to practice canceling, but with 2-handers, particularly the 2h-sword, the time you’re unable to move for your first attack feels unreasonably long at 2 seconds. On top of that, the time between when your attack actually concludes (you are no longer dealing damage or staggering your opponent) and when you’re able to move again also feels silly long and leaves you extremely vulnerable for an entire second for… no good reason.
Nevermind players, even npc’s and bosses have enough time to hit you back when the delay is that long, even if you’re actively trying to avoid them through positioning and making use of your range. Unwielding shortened this delay to 1 second and allowed you to move while your weapon was resetting, which made it possible to actually use these weapons without being anywhere from 4 to 8 times slower.
Between the 1h sword and 2h sword, the argument of “inertia” can be used to justify that the big sword should have a harsher recovery, and that’s fair. But a difference of 8x the time to recover feels both wrong from a math standpoint and unfair from a gameplay standpoint.
I am willing to bet that the other 2h weapons have similar inconsistencies in their timings. Apart from the daggers, the only 2h weapon I’ve used that feels like it has normal pacing between its attacks and recoveries is the katana.
Fair enough.
That said, rather than keeping animation canceling, wouldn’t you too prefer it if the weapon was viable and useful without such a trick as wield/unwield between attacks? Playing as it’s meant to be played, rather than playing the way we have to play because the weapon design is flawed?
Real world weapons are fast and nimble. Greatswords, and even things like two-handed axes. A weapon that causes its wielder to lose balance and require a second to recover is suicide. I understand game balance reasons to make more powerful weapons slower, especially if they have an area attack - but that’s not something one should circumvent by animation canceling. It’s not something you should need to circumvent.
So I suggest a paradigm shift to this whole discussion: rather than debating whether animation canceling is good, bad or ugly. perhaps we should discuss what Funcom should do to various weapons so as not to necessitate such gamey maneuvers.
This is where the developers want the discussion and the game to go. Instead of being shackled to a bug such as animation canceling. They want to be able to have a discussion on making more weapons viable, more weapon options, and more playstyle options.
I really wish those people who want to keep the canceling were simply ignorant to this. But over the years, I have found people aren’t nearly as dumb(ignorant) or naïve as they sometimes appear to be. Personal bias and complacency is what drives their argument.
So far the arguments and claims have been… weird and strange. For example, one of the arguments is that 1v3 will no longer be possible. The same people complain of empty servers. So where are these common place 1v3’s happening? Yeah it doesn’t make sense and appears to be contradictory at best. Nevermind the fact that even if the servers they play on weren’t empty, that a 1v3 is infeasible in either 2.3 or 2.4
Another argument is the one of a newbie off the cross will have a 50/50 chance against a 5,000 hour veteran. I could break this down… but I doubt I need to. Anyone reading this will be like, “wtf are they talking about?” Again this is just weird.
Yet another argument says the game feels clunky. Let’s break this down:
Click(miss), X, X, Click(miss) X, X, Click(hit), Click(miss), X, X, etc.
Or that’s if they are using it in the manner they claim to be. It actually works more like this:
Click Macro, Click Macro, Click Macro
Where the Macro is: Click, X, X and they spam the attack.
Funny thing is another macro has been found to animation cancel in 2.4, which is why many of these posts have been dying down over the last 30 hours. They’ll come back in 2.4.1 to complain again once that’s patched out in the hotfix.
And finally… we have the argument that PVE players are ruining the experience for PVP. Claiming the removal of animation canceling was to sate the desires of PVE players. I would say that 90% of PVE players don’t even know what animation canceling is. And a good portion of that have never even heard of it prior to 2.4
This one is weird because there is no forum posts, no bug reports, no youtube videos, reddit posts, or even discord conversations between any PVE groups of players even discussing animation canceling. Well the explanation is easy, if not clear. Its an attempted marginalization of other PVP players who requested animation canceling to be looked at. Claiming they are not ‘real PVPers’.
Well the truth of the matter is quite clear. The devs don’t like it. They’ve played on servers (private) that had banned the practice for months if not years. And enjoyed the combat better there. Make sense, its the combat they designed as intended.
But the whole thing that is weird and strange is they make up all these situational hypotheticals, unsubstantiated claims, and downright personally attack those who don’t agree in very weak and ineffectual ways. Many of them got banned/suspended for pretty much tantrums (many forum threads got shorter in the last few days). And what makes that weird is they are not going to get what they want by doing that. Surely they know this.
But back to the point you were making Kapoteeni, with why isn’t the discussion on making the weapons feel better in their usage, make the responses quicker and smoother if needed? I did someone bring up a comparison between two handed swords and one handed weapons. They asked why the two hander was a 2 second swing compared to a quarter second swing on a one hander when they only do like 30-40% more damage? That’s a valid question.
But instead of having a discussion we might actually all be able to come to some sort of consensus or at least a civil conversation on. Its Funcom is bad, Funcom doesn’t care, PVE ruins the game, and even in some cases, racist comments for no reason. Thankfully that last one was cleaned up a tad.
I guess the idea of an evolving and dynamic meta being developed and becoming the new future is the real culprit behind their angst on this subject. But in my opinion, a dynamic meta keeps a game fresh. Complacency and routine shouldn’t be a norm.
I agree, it shouldn’t be necessary to go to that length. But I was happy with wielding and unwielding, as were a significant number of others. Scroll up and you’ll find that some only voted no on ‘canceling’ because the vote was vague, and the broad spectrum of ‘canceling’ included game-breaking exploits involving rope in the offhand. The unwield and wield wasn’t taken as that.
Having said that, if one would want to fill the hole left by removing the option to unwield and wield again, there’s 3 things I would ask for:
- Better timing to the weapon, especially recovery time, so it’s possible to back out and agiley weave in and out of the fight.
- The ability to feint and mislead with false attacks, so you can add a layer of mind games to the pvp combat.
- The ability to stop a combo chain from continuing, or prevent an attack early in its swing to avoid friendly fire/undesired attacks.
Unwield+wield made all of these possible through a single mechanic. It may not have been visually pretty, and it may not have been put forward as an intended feature, but it accounted for these 3 issues perfectly and didn’t break the game since there were still consequences for unwielding, and you could use it unskillfully as much as you could use it skillfully.
This is the part where you might say ‘but dodging’ and in return I’ll say: Do you think it should be necessary to hurl your entire body in an ‘immune-to-everything’ roll just to weave, feint or avoid friendly fire? There should be a less extreme option here.
If Funcom can reintroduce these pieces of combat that made it freaking fantastic to fight in this game, I’ll be happy. If not, I’m going to be grumpy til the end of time because despite “adjusting” to the way fights play out now, combat doesn’t feel the same and I’m constantly annoyed that it’s a much slower and clumsier exchange, regardless of if it’s pve or pvp.
And actually useless once you have multiple fridges and 1000 8n stash for random recipe needs.
My clan mates have adapted the pve farming techniques tbh. That is all I am saying. The pvpers who don’t are the ones who dis pve and rp. Hell, we all rp…just at different levels.